Congress Deadlocked Over How To Not Provide Health Care
AUGUST 18, 2009 | ISSUE 45•34
WASHINGTON—After months of committee meetings and hundreds of hours of
heated debate, the United States Congress remained deadlocked this
week over the best possible way to deny Americans health care.
"Both parties understand that the current system is broken," House
Speaker Nancy Pelosi told reporters Monday. "But what we can't seem to
agree upon is how to best keep it broken, while still ensuring that no
elected official takes any political risk whatsoever. It’s a very
"Ultimately, though, it's our responsibility as lawmakers to put these
differences aside and focus on refusing Americans the health care they
deserve," Pelosi added.
The legislative stalemate largely stems from competing ideologies
deeply rooted along party lines. Democrats want to create a
government-run system for not providing health care, while Republicans
say coverage is best denied by allowing private insurers to make it
unaffordable for as many citizens as possible.
"We have over 40 million people without insurance in this country
today, and that is unacceptable," Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT) said. "If we
would just quit squabbling so much, we could get that number up to 50
or even 100 million. Why, there's no reason we can't work together to
deny health care to everyone but the richest 1 percent of the
"That's what America is all about," he added.
House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-OH) said on Meet The Press that
Republicans would never agree to a plan that doesn't allow citizens
the choice to be denied medical care in the private sector.
"Americans don't need some government official telling them they don't
have the proper coverage to receive treatment," Boehner said. "What
they need is massive insurance companies to become even more rich and
powerful by withholding from average citizens the care they so
desperately require. We're talking about people's health and the
obscene profits associated with that, after all."
Though there remain irreconcilable points, both parties have reached
some common ground in recent weeks. Senate leaders Harry Reid (D-NV)
and Mitch McConnell (R-KY) point to Congress' failure to pass
legislation before a July 31 deadline as proof of just how serious
lawmakers are about stringing along the American people and never
actually reforming the health care industry in any meaningful way.
"People should know that every day we are working without their best
interests in mind," Reid said. "But the goal here is not to push
through some watered-down bill that only denies health care to a few
Americans here and a few Americans there. The goal is to recognize
that all Americans have a God-given right to proper medical attention
and then make sure there's no chance in hell that ever happens."
"No matter what we come up with," Reid continued, "rest assured that
millions of citizens will remain dangerously uninsured, and the
inflated health care industry will continue to bankrupt the country
Other lawmakers stressed that, while there has been some progress, the
window of cooperation was closing.
"When you get into the nuts and bolts of how best not to provide
people with care essential to their survival, there are many things to
take into consideration," Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-MN) said. "I
believe we can create a plan for Americans that allows them to not be
able to go to the hospital, not get the treatment they need, and
ultimately whither away and die. But we've got to act fast."
For his part, President Barack Obama claimed to be optimistic, even
saying he believes that a health care denial bill will pass in both
houses of Congress by the end of the year.
"We have an opportunity to do something truly historic in 2009," Obama
said to a mostly silent crowd during a town hall meeting in Virginia
yesterday. "I promise I will only sign a clear and comprehensive
health care bill that fully denies coverage to you, your sick mother,
her husband, middle-class Americans, single-parent households, the
unemployed, and most importantly, anyone in need of emergency medical
"This administration is committed to not providing health care," Obama
added. "Not just for this generation of Americans, but for many
generations to come."